Seriously Good. Questionably Innocent.
Small-batch cookies and sweet treats baked to satisfy your cravings, tempt your taste buds, and occasionally get you into trouble.
Welcome to GUILTY AS BAKED! Boutique Micro-Bakery — where cravings are taken seriously, but ourselves? Not so much. We create big, bold, ridiculously good cookies and sweet treats in small batches, using quality ingredients, creative flavor combinations, and absolutely no interest in behaving ourselves. Our indulgences aren't shy: some are buttery and classic, some are loaded to the point of questionable judgment, and some take nostalgic favorites and give them a serious upgrade. Every now and then, something particularly dangerous gets released on PAROLE for a limited time. From sophisticated flavor combinations to unapologetically indulgent creations, GUILTY AS BAKED! is all about turning an ordinary sweet treat into an experience worth talking about. Because you shouldn't have to choose between really good and really fun. So go ahead—indulge a little. We won't tell.
Get first access to drops, pre-orders, and announcements
Enter your email to unlock the full experience with GUILTY AS BAKED! — track orders, get notifications, and more.
Benefits:
- Track orders
- Live chat with GUILTY AS BAKED!
- Customize notifications
- Benefit from loyalty rewards
Why choose GUILTY AS BAKED!
Ordinary cookies have had their chance. We bake small-batch, ridiculously indulgent treats with quality ingredients, bold flavors, and absolutely no interest in being boring.
SMALL BATCHES
Because good cookies deserve attention. Proceed with delicious intent.
REAL INGREDIENTS
No shortcuts. No boring cookies. Big Flavors. Questionable Restraint.
MADE FRESH FOR YOU
Baked fresh in small batches, with care. Because guilty should come with delicious evidence.
SECURE CHECKOUT
Your payment stays private. Your cookie addiction is between us. We have an alibi. 😏
Featured Creations
Discover our most beloved items, each crafted with passion and the finest ingredients
Seasonal Offender
SEASONAL OFFENDER NEW OFFENDER ON THE LOOSE We tried to keep this one under control. We failed. A thick, indulgent pumpkin cookie made with brown butter, real pumpkin, warm fall spices, and creamy white chocolate. It’s cozy. It’s buttery. It’s spiced just right. And that creamy white chocolate? Exhibit A. But don't get too attached... PAROLE STATUS: LIMITED SEASONAL RELEASE Once the season is over, this offender goes back into custody. The evidence is seasonal. The offense is delicious.
Lemon Larceny
CAUGHT IN THE ACT OF BEING DELICIOUS This one didn't just steal the spotlight. It stole the lemons. 🍋 LEMON LARCENY is a bold, bright lemon cookie with a white chocolate bottom and a delicate lemon glaze that brings just the right finishing touch. Citrusy. Creamy. Sweet with a little attitude. And subtle? Absolutely not. Too bold to be subtle. Too good to get caught! Consider this your warning: One bite, and you're officially an accomplice.
Double Jeopardy
TWO CHOCOLATES. ONE SERIOUSLY DELICIOUS OFFENSE. This one has no alibi. DOUBLE JEOPARDY starts with a rich, nutty brown-butter cookie, then gets loaded with two kinds of chocolate—decadent chocolate chips and creamy milk chocolate chunks. Finished with just a delicate touch of flaky sea salt to make all that chocolate hit a little harder. The evidence? All in the inside. No alibi. No accomplices. Just two chocolates and absolutely no regrets. DOUBLE JEOPARDY The evidence... all in the inside.
Fudge on the Run
FUDGE ON THE RUN ESCAPED. DECADENT. EXTREMELY GUILTY. This one didn’t wait for permission. A rich, fudgy chocolate crinkle cookie that broke out of the ordinary and hit the road. Deep chocolate flavor, a soft, brownie-like center, and that signature crinkled top dusted in powdered sugar. Then we caught it trying to make a run for it… and gave it a raspberry drizzle for evidence. The verdict? Guilty of being ridiculously delicious. STATUS: AT LARGE CHARGE: FUDGE EVIDENCE: THE RASPBERRY DRIZZLE
Create your own Box (4 Cookies)
Fill a box with your choice of cookies! Customize it how you want!
Create your own Box
IT STARTED INNOCENTLY ENOUGH…
It started innocently enough: a little baking, a little humor, and a whim that got completely out of hand. What began as a fun quirky idea quickly turned into a passion for creating indulgent, over-the-top treats worth getting caught with. Welcome to GUILTY AS BAKED! —where the evidence is delicious.